Gabby Petito’s Parents Sue Moab Police for $50 Million: What Utah Families Need to Know About Wrongful Death Claims Against Government Agencies

Gabby Petito’s Parents Sue Moab Police for $50 Million: What Utah Families Need to Know About Wrongful Death Claims Against Government Agencies

Few cases in recent memory have drawn as much national attention as the death of Gabby Petito. Her parents, Joseph Petito and Nichole Schmidt, filed a $50 million wrongful death lawsuit against the Moab City Police Department in November 2022. The case is back in the news as it heads to the Utah Supreme Court. Their legal fight raises a question that matters to every Utah family: when can a government agency be held responsible for a death, and what stands in the way?

For Utah residents, the case is about more than one tragedy. It tests how far the Governmental Immunity Act of Utah protects police departments and other public entities from wrongful death claims. It also tests whether the Utah Constitution limits that protection. The outcome could shape what families can recover after a public agency’s alleged failure contributes to a loved one’s death.

Background: The Moab Traffic Stop and the Lawsuit

The lawsuit centers on an August 2021 traffic stop in Moab involving Gabby Petito and her fiancé, Brian Laundrie. Officers responded to reports of a possible domestic dispute. They separated the couple for the night and did not file charges. Petito was later killed, and her death led to a nationwide search and intense media coverage.

Her parents’ lawsuit alleges that Moab officers failed to recognize that Petito was a victim of domestic violence and mishandled the encounter. The suit describes the officers’ conduct as grossly negligent and claims it increased the risk of harm to her. An independent review of the police response, commissioned after her death, found that officers made “several unintentional mistakes.” The review also suggested that Petito was likely a long-term victim of domestic violence.

In November 2024, a Utah district judge dismissed the lawsuit, citing the protections of the Governmental Immunity Act. The family appealed. They argue that the immunity law is unconstitutional as applied to wrongful death claims. The Utah Supreme Court has scheduled oral argument for December 9, 2026, alongside a similar case brought by the family of Amanda Mayne. The State of Utah has filed a brief defending the Act’s constitutionality. These are allegations and legal arguments, and no court has made a final finding of liability.

Understanding Wrongful Death Claims

A wrongful death claim is a civil lawsuit brought when a person dies because of another party’s wrongful act or negligence. Unlike a criminal case, it does not seek punishment. It seeks compensation for the losses the surviving family suffers. A family can bring a wrongful death claim even when no criminal charges are filed, and even when the person most directly responsible has died. That is why families sometimes look beyond the immediate wrongdoer to other parties whose conduct may have contributed to the death.

To succeed, a wrongful death plaintiff generally must show:

  • Duty: The defendant owed the person who died a legal duty of care.
  • Breach: The defendant failed to meet that duty.
  • Causation: The breach caused or contributed to the death.
  • Damages: The surviving family suffered measurable losses as a result.

Claims against law enforcement are especially complex. Courts often limit when police owe a duty to protect a specific person from harm caused by a third party. Immunity statutes add another layer. Families exploring these claims can learn more on the Maxx Compensation wrongful death practice page.

Utah Wrongful Death Law: What Families Should Know

Who Can File

Under Utah’s wrongful death statute, Utah Code § 78B-3-106, a claim may be brought by the decedent’s heirs or by the personal representative of the decedent’s estate on the heirs’ behalf. Heirs typically include a spouse, children, and, in some circumstances, parents. That is why Gabby Petito’s parents could bring the claim.

Statute of Limitations

Utah generally requires families to file a wrongful death action within two years of the death under Utah Code § 78B-2-304. Missing this deadline can permanently bar the claim. Different and shorter deadlines apply when the defendant is a government entity, as explained below.

Comparative Fault

Utah follows a modified comparative fault system under the Liability Reform Act, Utah Code § 78B-5-818. A plaintiff can recover damages only if their fault is less than the combined fault of the defendants. Any award is reduced by the plaintiff’s share of fault. Utah also allows fault to be allocated among multiple parties, including people who are not named in the lawsuit. In cases with several potentially responsible parties, how a jury divides fault can significantly affect what each defendant pays.

No Constitutional Cap on Wrongful Death Damages

Utah is unusual in that its constitution directly protects wrongful death claims. Article XVI, Section 5 of the Utah Constitution provides that the right to recover damages for injuries resulting in death “shall never be abrogated.” It also provides that the amount recoverable is not subject to statutory limitation, with limited exceptions. The Petito appeal relies on this provision. The family argues that applying governmental immunity to bar their wrongful death claim conflicts with it.

Suing a Government Entity in Utah: The Governmental Immunity Act

When a public entity such as a city police department is involved, the Governmental Immunity Act of Utah (Utah Code Title 63G, Chapter 7) controls. The Act sets rules that differ sharply from ordinary negligence claims:

  • Notice of claim: A claimant generally must file a written notice of claim with the government entity within one year after the claim arises (Utah Code § 63G-7-402). Failing to file a proper, timely notice can be fatal to the case.
  • Waiting period: After filing the notice, the claimant must give the entity time to respond before filing suit. Strict deadlines then apply for bringing the lawsuit.
  • Retained immunity: The Act waives immunity for some negligent acts. It keeps immunity for many others, including certain discretionary functions and specific law enforcement activities listed in Utah Code § 63G-7-201.
  • Damage limits: Even when immunity is waived, the Act caps the damages that can be recovered against a government entity (Utah Code § 63G-7-604). The cap is adjusted periodically.

These rules explain why the Petito case turns on constitutional questions rather than only on what happened during the traffic stop. If the Utah Supreme Court finds the Act unconstitutional as applied to wrongful death claims, families in similar situations may have broader options in the future. If the court upholds the Act, the existing barriers will remain.

Legal Options for Families After a Wrongful Death

Families who believe negligence contributed to a loved one’s death may have several paths, depending on the facts:

  • Claims against the individual responsible: A family can bring a civil claim against the person who directly caused the death, or against that person’s estate.
  • Claims against third parties: Employers, property owners, businesses, or other parties whose negligence contributed to the harm may share responsibility.
  • Claims against government entities: These are subject to the Governmental Immunity Act’s notice requirements, immunity exceptions, and damage caps.
  • Federal civil rights claims: In some cases, federal claims under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 may be available when government officials violate constitutional rights. These claims carry their own demanding standards, including qualified immunity.

Recoverable damages in a Utah wrongful death case may include funeral and burial costs, medical expenses, lost financial support, and the loss of the decedent’s love, companionship, care, and guidance. Every case is different, and laws vary by state. Families should consult an experienced attorney about their specific circumstances. More information is available on the wrongful death claims page.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does a family have to file a wrongful death claim in Utah?

Utah generally allows two years from the date of death to file a wrongful death lawsuit under Utah Code § 78B-2-304. If a government entity may be responsible, a notice of claim usually must be filed within one year under the Governmental Immunity Act. Because these deadlines are strict, families should speak with an attorney as early as possible.

Can a family sue the police for a wrongful death in Utah?

Sometimes, but it is difficult. The Governmental Immunity Act of Utah keeps immunity for many law enforcement activities and caps the damages that can be recovered against public entities. The Petito appeal asks the Utah Supreme Court whether applying that immunity to wrongful death claims violates the Utah Constitution. The court’s decision could change the law in this area.

Does Utah cap damages in wrongful death cases?

Article XVI, Section 5 of the Utah Constitution provides that wrongful death recoveries generally shall not be subject to statutory limitation. However, claims against government entities are subject to the damage caps in the Governmental Immunity Act. Separate rules may also apply in certain other claim types. An attorney can explain which rules apply to a particular case.

Speak With a Wrongful Death Attorney Today

Losing a loved one is devastating, and pursuing a legal claim can feel overwhelming. That is especially true when a government agency, strict notice deadlines, or immunity rules are involved. The attorneys at Maxx Compensation help grieving families understand their rights and pursue the accountability and compensation they deserve.

If your family has lost someone because of another party’s negligence, contact Maxx Compensation for a free, confidential consultation. Call 877-462-9952 today to discuss your options. Utah deadlines can be short, so acting promptly may protect your family’s ability to recover.

Jackie:

Get A Free Consultation