CHP Agrees to $7 Million Settlement in Officer-Involved Wrongful Death Lawsuit: What California Families Should Know
By Charles C. Teale
The California Highway Patrol (CHP) has agreed to pay $7 million to settle a wrongful death lawsuit over an officer-involved death, according to a recent report in Law Commentary. A settlement of this size against a state law enforcement agency matters to many California families. It shows that public agencies, including the state’s largest police force, can be held financially responsible when a death occurs during an encounter with officers.
Behind every case like this is a family dealing with a sudden and painful loss. They also face a legal process that works very differently from an ordinary injury claim. When the defendant is a government agency, California law sets special deadlines, procedures and limits. Families who don’t know these rules can lose their right to recover before they realize a claim exists. This article explains the legal concepts behind officer-involved wrongful death claims in California and the options surviving family members may have.
Why the CHP Settlement Matters to California Residents
The CHP patrols highways, freeways and unincorporated areas across the state. Most Californians encounter its officers at some point. When a lawsuit against the agency ends in a multimillion-dollar settlement, it is a reminder that government employees are not beyond the reach of civil law. A settlement is not necessarily an admission of wrongdoing, and the terms of any agreement belong to the parties. Still, resolutions like this show that families have legal tools to pursue accountability and compensation after a loved one dies in an encounter with law enforcement.
These cases also shape public policy. Civil litigation is one of the main ways agency practices, training and use-of-force decisions get examined in detail. The process often brings out records and testimony that might otherwise never become public.
Understanding Wrongful Death Claims in California
A wrongful death claim lets certain surviving family members seek compensation when someone dies because of another person’s or entity’s wrongful act or negligence. In California, these claims are governed by Code of Civil Procedure § 377.60, which lists who may bring the action. Eligible people generally include:
- The surviving spouse or registered domestic partner
- The deceased person’s children, and the issue of any deceased children
- If none of those people exist, others who would inherit under California’s intestate succession laws
- In certain circumstances, putative spouses, stepchildren, parents, or minors who lived in the household and depended on the deceased person
California also recognizes a separate survival action under Code of Civil Procedure § 377.30, brought by the personal representative of the deceased person’s estate. A wrongful death claim compensates family members for their own losses. A survival action pursues the claims the deceased person could have brought if they had lived. The two are often filed together. Families working through these overlapping claims can find more information on the firm’s wrongful death practice area page.
Legal Theories in Officer-Involved Death Cases
Lawsuits arising from deaths in police encounters often combine state and federal claims. The main legal theories usually include the following.
State Law Negligence and Battery
Under Government Code § 815.2, a California public entity can be vicariously liable for injuries caused by its employees acting within the scope of their employment. Families may therefore pursue negligence or battery claims against the agency itself. The California Supreme Court held in Hayes v. County of San Diego (2013) that an officer’s tactical conduct before using deadly force can be considered as part of the totality of circumstances in a negligence claim.
California’s Use-of-Force Standard
In 2019 the Legislature amended Penal Code § 835a through Assembly Bill 392. The amendment provides that officers may use deadly force only when it is necessary in defense of human life, based on the totality of the circumstances. This standard is often central to how courts and juries evaluate an officer’s conduct in a civil case.
The Tom Bane Civil Rights Act
Civil Code § 52.1, known as the Bane Act, allows claims when a person’s constitutional or statutory rights are interfered with by threats, intimidation or coercion. It is frequently raised in excessive force cases.
Federal Civil Rights Claims
Families may also bring claims under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 for violations of constitutional rights, such as the Fourth Amendment’s protection against unreasonable seizures. One technical point applies here. Under federal precedent, a state agency like the CHP generally is not a “person” that can be sued for damages under § 1983. Individual officers, however, may be named, subject to defenses such as qualified immunity. How federal and state claims are structured against the right defendants can significantly affect the outcome.
California-Specific Deadlines: The Government Claims Act
The most important rule for families to understand is the Government Claims Act (Government Code § 810 et seq.). Before a lawsuit for money damages can be filed against a California public entity such as the CHP, a written claim must be presented to that entity first.
- Six-month claim deadline: Under Government Code § 911.2, a claim for death or personal injury must be presented within six months after the cause of action accrues.
- Late claim relief: Under Government Code § 911.4, a claimant who misses the six-month window may apply for permission to file a late claim. The application must be made within one year, and relief is not guaranteed.
- Deadline to sue after rejection: Under Government Code § 945.6, if the entity sends written notice rejecting the claim, the family generally has six months from that notice to file a lawsuit. If no written notice is given, the period is generally two years from accrual.
Compare this with the general rule for wrongful death claims against private parties. Under Code of Civil Procedure § 335.1, those claims usually carry a two-year statute of limitations. Federal § 1983 claims filed in California generally borrow that same two-year period. Because the government claim deadline is much shorter, families who wait to consult an attorney risk losing state law claims entirely.
Comparative Fault in California
California follows a pure comparative negligence system, established by the California Supreme Court in Li v. Yellow Cab Co. (1975). Under this rule, compensation is reduced by any percentage of fault assigned to the injured or deceased person, but it is not barred entirely. In officer-involved cases, defendants often argue that the deceased person’s own conduct contributed to the outcome. A jury may weigh those arguments. Even when some fault is assigned, the family can still recover a share of damages.
California also follows Proposition 51 (Civil Code § 1431.2). When multiple defendants share responsibility, each defendant’s liability for non-economic damages is limited to its own share of fault.
Damages and Caps
California does not impose a general cap on wrongful death damages. The caps under the Medical Injury Compensation Reform Act (MICRA) apply only to medical malpractice cases. Recoverable wrongful death damages may include:
- Loss of financial support the deceased person would have provided
- Loss of household services
- Funeral and burial expenses
- Loss of love, companionship, comfort, care, affection, moral support and guidance
There are also limits. California does not award damages for the family’s grief or sorrow itself, although the closely related loss of companionship is compensable. Under Government Code § 818, punitive damages cannot be recovered against a public entity, though they may be available against individual officers under certain federal claims. California law on pain-and-suffering damages in survival actions has also changed in recent years. Families should ask an attorney how the current rules apply to their case.
Because laws vary by state and these cases involve complex questions of procedure and immunity, families should consult an experienced attorney about their specific circumstances. More information about how these claims are evaluated is on the Maxx Compensation wrongful death page.
What Families Should Do After an Officer-Involved Death
- Act quickly. The six-month Government Claims Act deadline starts early and is strictly enforced.
- Preserve evidence. Keep any photos, videos, texts, social media posts and witness contact information. Body-worn camera and dash camera footage may be requested through counsel or public records laws.
- Request records. California Penal Code § 832.7, as amended by SB 1421 and SB 16, makes certain records about officer uses of force available to the public.
- Be cautious with statements. Families should be careful about giving recorded statements to agency investigators or insurers without legal guidance.
- Consult an attorney. An attorney can identify the correct defendants, file the government claim on time and coordinate state and federal claims.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a family sue the California Highway Patrol for a wrongful death?
Yes, in many circumstances. Under the Government Code, a public entity can be held vicariously liable for its employees’ wrongful acts within the scope of their employment. First, the family generally must present a written government claim within six months of the death. Federal civil rights claims are generally brought against individual officers rather than the agency itself.
How long does a family have to file a wrongful death claim against a California government agency?
In most cases, the claim must be presented to the agency within six months under Government Code § 911.2. If the claim is rejected in writing, the family typically has six months from the rejection notice to file a lawsuit. These deadlines are much shorter than the two-year period that usually applies to claims against private parties, so prompt legal advice is essential.
Does a settlement mean the officer or agency admitted fault?
Not necessarily. Settlements often resolve claims without any admission of liability. A public agency may settle to avoid the cost and uncertainty of trial. A settlement can still provide meaningful compensation and closure for a grieving family.
Speak With a California Wrongful Death Attorney
Losing a loved one in an encounter with law enforcement leaves families with grief and difficult questions. They also face strict legal deadlines that begin running almost immediately. The team at Maxx Compensation helps families understand their rights, meet critical filing requirements and pursue full compensation from those responsible.
Call Maxx Compensation today at 877-462-9952 for a free, confidential consultation. There is no obligation, and families can learn what options may be available before important deadlines pass.
