$28 Million Firetruck Crash Verdict: What Vermont Victims Should Know About Suing a Fire Department

A Los Angeles jury has awarded $28 million to a motorcyclist who lost a leg after a collision with a Los Angeles Fire Department firetruck, according to KTLA. The verdict shows something many injured people don’t realize: a government agency, including the fire department, can be held financially responsible when one of its vehicles causes a life-altering injury.

The case was decided under California law, but the same question comes up in Vermont. Fire engines, ambulances, plow trucks, and other municipal and state vehicles share Vermont’s roads every day, often on narrow two-lane highways and in winter conditions. A crash with one of these heavy vehicles can be devastating, especially for a motorcyclist. When the at-fault driver works for a town, city, or the State of Vermont, the route to compensation is different from an ordinary crash claim, and missing a procedural step can cost a victim their case.

Why Crashes With Firetrucks and Government Vehicles Are Different

A fully loaded fire engine can weigh 40,000 pounds or more. A motorcycle rider has almost no protection against that weight, which is why these collisions so often cause catastrophic injuries such as amputations, traumatic brain injuries, spinal cord damage, and multiple fractures. Injuries like these mean lifelong medical care, prosthetics, lost earning capacity, and major changes to daily life.

Beyond how severe the injuries are, these cases raise legal issues that most car accident claims don’t:

  • Emergency vehicle privileges: Emergency drivers may bend some traffic rules when responding to a call, but those privileges have limits.
  • Government immunity: Public entities are protected by legal doctrines that limit when and how they can be sued.
  • Damage limits: Claims against the state may be capped by statute.
  • Defendant identification: The injured person must name the correct government entity, not just the individual driver.

Emergency Vehicle Privileges Under Vermont Law

Vermont gives drivers of authorized emergency vehicles certain privileges. Under 23 V.S.A. § 1015, an emergency vehicle responding to a call and using its required lights and siren may, under specified conditions, go through a red signal or stop sign after slowing down as needed for safety, exceed the speed limit, and disregard some rules on direction of travel and turning.

The privilege is not unlimited. The statute states that these provisions do not relieve the driver of the duty to drive with due regard for the safety of all persons. They also do not protect the driver from the consequences of reckless disregard for the safety of others. In practice, a firetruck driver who speeds through a blind intersection without slowing or without proper warning signals may still be found negligent.

Other motorists have duties too. Vermont law requires drivers to yield the right-of-way and pull over when an emergency vehicle approaches with its lights and siren on. Whether the emergency vehicle was using its warning devices, whether other drivers could reasonably have heard or seen it, and whether the emergency driver used appropriate caution are often the central factual questions in these cases.

Suing a Vermont Town, City, or the State

Claims Against the State of Vermont

When a state employee causes a crash while acting within the scope of employment, the claim usually falls under the Vermont Tort Claims Act, 12 V.S.A. § 5601 et seq. The Act waives the state’s sovereign immunity for certain negligence claims, generally to the same extent a private person would be liable. The claim is brought against the State, not the individual employee. The Act also caps damages, currently set at $500,000 per person and $2,000,000 per occurrence, and it has exceptions, including some discretionary functions, that can bar certain claims altogether.

Claims Against Municipalities and Fire Departments

Most Vermont fire departments are run by towns, cities, or fire districts. Under 24 V.S.A. § 901, when a municipal employee acting within the scope of employment causes injury, the lawsuit generally must be brought against the municipality rather than the employee personally.

Vermont municipalities have traditionally been immune from liability for “governmental” functions, and firefighting is usually treated as one. However, 29 V.S.A. § 1403 provides that a municipality that buys liability insurance waives its immunity to the extent of that coverage. In many cases, the municipality’s insurance policy, often obtained through a municipal risk pool, determines how much compensation is realistically available. An attorney handling a claim against a Vermont town will usually need to look closely at the coverage documents early on.

Vermont Statute of Limitations

Under 12 V.S.A. § 512(4), most personal injury lawsuits in Vermont must be filed within three years of the injury. Property damage claims generally have a three-year deadline as well. If a crash causes a death, Vermont’s wrongful death statute, 14 V.S.A. § 1492, generally requires the action to be brought within two years of the date of death, subject to limited exceptions.

Three years can seem like plenty of time, but claims against government entities often need early investigation. Dispatch records, vehicle data, dashcam footage, radio logs, and maintenance records may be kept for only a limited time under public records retention schedules. Acting quickly helps preserve the evidence that proves fault.

Comparative Negligence in Vermont

Vermont follows a modified comparative negligence rule under 12 V.S.A. § 1036. An injured person can recover damages as long as their own negligence was not greater than the combined negligence of the defendants. Any recovery is reduced by the injured person’s percentage of fault. For example, a rider found 20 percent at fault would recover 80 percent of the total damages. A rider found more than 50 percent at fault would recover nothing.

In emergency vehicle cases, defendants often argue that the injured motorist failed to yield, was speeding, or was not paying attention. Motorcyclists may also face arguments about visibility, lane position, or safety gear. Vermont has a universal helmet requirement under 23 V.S.A. § 1256, and defense attorneys sometimes try to use safety equipment to reduce damages. Because the allocation of fault directly affects the amount recovered, a thorough accident reconstruction is often essential.

Damages Available to Injured Victims

In a successful Vermont personal injury claim, an injured person may seek compensation for:

  • Past and future medical expenses, including surgery, rehabilitation, and prosthetics
  • Lost wages and diminished future earning capacity
  • Pain and suffering and emotional distress
  • Loss of enjoyment of life
  • Permanent disfigurement or disability
  • Property damage, including the motorcycle and riding gear

Vermont does not cap compensatory damages in ordinary personal injury cases against private parties. In claims against the State, the Tort Claims Act caps described above apply. In claims against municipalities, recovery may be limited by available insurance coverage. That’s why it matters to identify every potentially responsible party, such as a private contractor, a vehicle manufacturer, or another negligent driver, and every applicable insurance policy, including the victim’s own underinsured motorist coverage.

For more on how these claims work, see the personal injury practice area overview.

Steps to Take After a Crash With a Government Vehicle

  • Get medical care right away and follow all treatment recommendations.
  • Request the police report and note the responding agency and vehicle number.
  • Identify witnesses and keep their contact information.
  • Photograph the scene, vehicles, injuries, and road conditions if possible.
  • Avoid recorded statements to the government entity’s insurer before getting legal advice.
  • Consult an attorney promptly so evidence such as dispatch logs and vehicle data can be preserved.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can someone in Vermont sue a fire department if a firetruck caused their accident?

Often, yes. Vermont municipalities generally waive governmental immunity to the extent of their liability insurance under 29 V.S.A. § 1403, and claims against the State are governed by the Vermont Tort Claims Act. Emergency drivers must still drive with due regard for the safety of others under 23 V.S.A. § 1015. Whether a claim is viable depends on the facts, the responsible entity, and the available insurance coverage.

How long does an injured person have to file a claim in Vermont?

Most personal injury claims must be filed within three years of the injury under 12 V.S.A. § 512(4). Wrongful death claims generally must be filed within two years of the date of death under 14 V.S.A. § 1492. Exceptions can apply, and government claims may involve additional procedural requirements, so getting legal advice early is strongly recommended.

Would a verdict like the $28 million award in Los Angeles be possible in Vermont?

Every case is different, and the Los Angeles verdict was decided under California law. In Vermont, claims against the State are capped by statute, and recovery against municipalities may be limited by insurance coverage. Claims involving private parties, such as contractors or other drivers, are not subject to those government-specific limits. An experienced attorney can identify every source of recovery.

Speak With an Attorney About a Vermont Accident Claim

Crashes involving firetrucks, ambulances, and other government vehicles raise complex questions about immunity, insurance coverage, emergency vehicle privileges, and shared fault. Laws vary by state, and the details of each case matter. Anyone who has been seriously injured, or who has lost a loved one, in a crash with a government or commercial vehicle should consult a qualified attorney about their rights.

Maxx Compensation helps accident victims understand their legal options and pursue the compensation they deserve. Learn more about personal injury claims, or call 877-462-9952 today for a free consultation. There is no obligation, and speaking with an experienced personal injury attorney is the first step toward protecting a claim.

By Charles C. Teale

Request a Free Injury Consultation Today

Initial consultations on all injury cases are complimentary. There are no attorney fees on personal injury cases unless you receive a settlement or a favorable verdict in your case. There is no risk or obligation to you to contact us today for your free consultation.

The use of this contact form or website for communication with our firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Please do not send confidential or time sensitive information.